A free process control resource from Wastewater Solutions, Inc.help@ActivatedSludge.com  |  503-701-2766
ActivatedSludge.comPractical wastewater process control

Secondary Clarifiers

The secondary clarifier has two jobs: clarify (send clean water over the weir) and thicken (concentrate settled sludge for return). It fails when either job is overloaded.

Zones in a clarifier

Secondary clarifier zonesMixed liquor enters a center feed well, settles through a clear zone and settling zone, and thickens in a sludge blanket on the floor. Clear effluent flows over peripheral weirs; settled sludge is withdrawn as RAS and WAS.Mixed liquor in (center feed)Effluent weir and launderRAS / WASScumClear water zoneSettling zoneSludge blanket (thickening zone)
Secondary clarifier zones: inlet and flocculation well, clear water zone, settling zone, sludge blanket and thickening zone, with RAS drawn from the floor.
  • Inlet and feed well: dissipate energy, encourage flocculation, spread flow.
  • Clear water zone: the top few feet; clarified effluent moves to the weirs.
  • Settling (hindered) zone: floc settles as a mass.
  • Blanket and thickening zone: sludge compacts before being drawn off.
  • Collector: scrapers or suction headers move sludge to the draw-off.

Loading rates

Surface overflow rate (SOR) = Q / surface area, gpd/ft². It controls clarification: the upward velocity of water must be less than the settling velocity of the floc. Typical design values for activated sludge are about 400 to 800 gpd/ft² average and 1,000 to 1,200 peak, depending on settleability.

Solids loading rate (SLR) = (Q + RAS) x MLSS x 8.34 / area, lb/d/ft². It controls thickening. Typical design values are about 20 to 30 lb/d/ft² average, up to about 40 to 50 at peak with good settling.

Weir overflow rate = Q / weir length, gpd/ft. Usually less critical with modern baffles.

White River example

Four 90 ft clarifiers, 25,447 ft² total. At design average 8.0 MGD:

SOR = 8,000,000 / 25,447 = 314 gpd/ft²

SLR = (8.0 + 4.0) x 3,000 x 8.34 / 25,447 = 11.8 lb/d/ft²

At peak hour (about 24 MGD design), SOR is about 943 gpd/ft² and SLR about 27.5 lb/d/ft².

Sludge blanket

Sludge blanket depthThree clarifiers show a normal blanket of 1 to 3 feet, a rising blanket of 4 to 6 feet that needs action, and a blanket near the weirs about to lose solids. A core sampler measures depth.Normalblanket 1 to 3 ftRisingblanket 4 to 6 ft: actNear losssolids at the weirsCore sampler or blanket finder
Measuring the sludge blanket with a core sampler. A shallow, stable blanket is the goal.

The blanket is your best real time indicator. Most plants aim for 1 to 3 ft (White River alarms at 4 ft). Measure every clarifier at the same time each day with a core sampler, sludge judge or blanket meter. A rising blanket means solids are arriving faster than they leave.

State point analysis

State point analysis compares the clarifier's thickening capacity (a flux curve built from settling tests) with the operating conditions (overflow and underflow lines). It shows whether the clarifier is underloaded, critically loaded or overloaded, and what RAS rate would help.

State point analysis diagramA gravity solids flux curve with an overflow line from the origin and an underflow line through the state point. Here the underflow line stays below the descending limb, so the clarifier is underloaded.024681012140123456State pointOverflow line, slope = Q/AUnderflow line, slope = -RAS/AGravity flux curveRAS concSolids concentration, g/LSolids flux, kg/m²·h
State point diagram: the flux curve, the overflow line (slope = SOR) and the underflow line (slope = underflow rate) meeting at the state point.

Try it with your own data in the state point tool.

Common problems

  • Rising blanket: thickening overload, low RAS, high SVI. Guide
  • Floating sludge: denitrification or septic sludge. Guide
  • Washout: hydraulic overload in storms. Guide
  • Cloudy effluent: pin floc, dispersed growth. Guide
  • Short circuiting: uneven weirs, density currents, missing baffles.
  • Mechanical: collector breakdowns, plugged suction headers, scum system failures.

Good habits

  • Measure blankets every shift.
  • Keep weirs level and clean.
  • Balance flow and RAS between clarifiers.
  • Run state point when SVI changes or storms are forecast.
  • Inspect collectors and drain each clarifier on a schedule.